SB Nation - Login for mobile commenting

Fake Teams

Keith Law's Top 100 Prospects Best Lineup

I saw someone post a best prospects lineup in the comment section of Kevin Goldstein's Top 101 prospects last Monday, so here is my shot at the 2012 Best Prospects Lineup based on Keith Law's Top 100 Prospects for 2012:

C-Travis d'Arnaud, TOR

1B-Anthony Rizzo, CHC

2B-Billy Hamilton, CIN*

SS- Manny Machado, BAL

3B-Anthony Rendon, WAS

OF-Mike Trout, LAA

OF-Bryce Harper, WAS

OF-Wil Myers, KC

DH-Jesus Montero, SEA

RHP-Shelby Miller, STL

LHP-Matt Moore, TB

And to round out the starting rotation for Keith's lineup:

RHP-Gerrit Cole, PIT

RHP-Dylan Bundy, BAL

RHP-Arodys Vizcaino, ATL

Some comments after the jump:

Star-divide

  • I had to push Reds shortstop prospect Billy Hamilton to second base as Law had no second base prospects in his Top 100 Prospect Rankings.
  • Royals outfield prospect Wil Myers barely beat out teammate Bubba Starling for the last outfield spot in the lineup, as Law ranking him two spots ahead of Starling at 13.
  • Nationals third base prospect Anthony Rendon, at #17, was ranked 9 spots ahead of Rockies third base prospect Nolan Arenado and 11 spots ahead of Twins third base prospect Miguel Sano.
  • Law's Top 100 list is certainly pitcher heavy as he ranked 26 pitchers in his Top 50 prospects for 2012.

0 recs  |  8 comments

Comments

this lineup

could this lineup beat the Astros or Cubs?

If they get 2-3 runs with Moore pitching, I don’t think the Astros have much of a chance 4 times out of 5.

I think

if this team could beat the Astros, these players would be in the majors.

He makes a good point though.

Matt Moore IS ready for the majors. The Astros would have a hard time scoring on Matt Moore.

To be fair though

So did the Rangers. And the Yankees.

Definitely. Moore is the difference maker here.
well

at least 7 of these guys will be in the big leagues this season.

You've just stunted the development of half of these guys!

You must Login with your SB Nation account and be a member of Fake Teams to post a comment.